Middle-earth: Shadow of War
Detailed Ratings
Gameplay 5.0/5
Story 3.0/5
Graphics 4.0/5
Soundtrack 4.0/5

Middle-earth: Shadow of War

Game
Released: 10/10/2017
+5
Balance
+5 -0
Score weighted by each hero's level: a recommendation from a level 3 hero counts for 3.
4.0/5
1
Reviews
Tome
From the editors, by Tome Updated on 18/04/2026

Orcs, bureaucracy, and the joy of turning cruelty into strategy

Middle Earth: Shadow of War arrives with the kind of confidence that only a franchise with major skin in the mythos can afford. It leans into an animosity you can manage, and that shift from “fight the enemy” to “build the enemy’s world” makes its combat stick. Even years later, people still talk about how it feels to watch a plan unfold in Mordor’s brutal, theatrical chaos.

The Experience

You play Talion, the ranger branded by the dark machinery of Middle-earth’s curse, now bound to a spirit-partner who hunts through the same shadowy geography that Tolkien readers know by name. The game throws you into a power struggle where climbing enemy ranks matters as much as swinging steel. Combat mixes stealth takedowns, brutal melee, and ranged pressure, then widens with faction conflict and a nemesis system that remembers who hurt you. Your loop becomes a cycle of scouting captains, breaking their control, recruiting or outmanealing rivals, and conquering forts that scale up from “territory” to “ecosystem.”

What Sets It Apart

Nemesis is the headline feature, but it is also the emotional engine: characters return with scars, reputations, and vendettas that make battles feel personal rather than scripted. Art direction stays faithful to Mordor’s grime and gothic scale, while the music leans into a tense, ritualistic grandeur that makes every siege sound like a ceremony gone wrong. Technically, the game focuses on readable encounters and sprawling fort layouts, prioritizing the feeling of momentum over quiet exploration. It sits inside developer Monolith Productions’s broader catalog of systems-driven action, and it firmly continues the series lineage from Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor.

Who Should Play This

If you like action games with management and character drama, this will click. Expect roughly 30 to 60 hours depending on how deep you go into side conquests and the nemesis web. Difficulty can spike when you hit tougher captains, but stealth, preparation, and upgrades do the heavy lifting. Available on PC, PlayStation, and Xbox, it is best enjoyed with the prequel’s context fresh, since Shadow of War builds on the established nemesis framework rather than starting from zero.

+5
Balance
+5 -0
Score weighted by each hero's level: a recommendation from a level 3 hero counts for 3.
4.0/5
1
Reviews
Detailed Ratings
Gameplay 5.0/5
Story 3.0/5
Graphics 4.0/5
Soundtrack 4.0/5
Tome
From the editors, by Tome Updated on 18/04/2026

Orcs, bureaucracy, and the joy of turning cruelty into strategy

Middle Earth: Shadow of War arrives with the kind of confidence that only a franchise with major skin in the mythos can afford. It leans into an animosity you can manage, and that shift from “fight the enemy” to “build the enemy’s world” makes its combat stick. Even years later, people still talk about how it feels to watch a plan unfold in Mordor’s brutal, theatrical chaos.

The Experience

You play Talion, the ranger branded by the dark machinery of Middle-earth’s curse, now bound to a spirit-partner who hunts through the same shadowy geography that Tolkien readers know by name. The game throws you into a power struggle where climbing enemy ranks matters as much as swinging steel. Combat mixes stealth takedowns, brutal melee, and ranged pressure, then widens with faction conflict and a nemesis system that remembers who hurt you. Your loop becomes a cycle of scouting captains, breaking their control, recruiting or outmanealing rivals, and conquering forts that scale up from “territory” to “ecosystem.”

What Sets It Apart

Nemesis is the headline feature, but it is also the emotional engine: characters return with scars, reputations, and vendettas that make battles feel personal rather than scripted. Art direction stays faithful to Mordor’s grime and gothic scale, while the music leans into a tense, ritualistic grandeur that makes every siege sound like a ceremony gone wrong. Technically, the game focuses on readable encounters and sprawling fort layouts, prioritizing the feeling of momentum over quiet exploration. It sits inside developer Monolith Productions’s broader catalog of systems-driven action, and it firmly continues the series lineage from Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor.

Who Should Play This

If you like action games with management and character drama, this will click. Expect roughly 30 to 60 hours depending on how deep you go into side conquests and the nemesis web. Difficulty can spike when you hit tougher captains, but stealth, preparation, and upgrades do the heavy lifting. Available on PC, PlayStation, and Xbox, it is best enjoyed with the prequel’s context fresh, since Shadow of War builds on the established nemesis framework rather than starting from zero.

Status: Completed
Publication: 2017
Age rating: Mature (18+)
Genres: RPG Open World Action-Adventure

Also in the Middle-earth universe

See all 11 works

Reviews

defiant-control

Bigger than Shadow of Mordor but perhaps not quite as strong

In almost every way, Shadow of War is bigger and more ambitious than its predecessor. It expands the famed Nemesis combat system, introduces fortress sieges as an endgame mode, and takes place in five separate environmental zones to add variety. Combat is just as strong as the first game, too, with responsive and satisfying swordplay mixed with extremely fun, gory finisher moves. Shadow of War also leaned really heavily into creating tons of interesting enemy captains that have unique voice acting and personalities.

On the negative side, the story is non-canon and will likely bother hardcore LotR fans. I also found the dialogue to be a little lackluster. But it's still an 8-9 for me.
Recommends:
+5 The value of a recommendation depends on its author's level.
Overall
Gameplay
Story
Graphics
Soundtrack
22
Compete in the Heroes' Tournament and win Amazon gift cards! Discover